The following excerpt is from an article that originally appeared on Hit and Run
Is there a good defense of BuzzFeed‘s decision to publish the Urinegate memos last night? Glenn Greenwald’s analysis of the story makes the best argument I’ve seen, though there are so many caveats here that I don’t think it quite qualifies as a defense:
It’s almost impossible to imagine a scenario where it’s justifiable for a news outlet to publish a totally anonymous, unverified, unvetted document filled with scurrilous and inflammatory allegations about which its own editor-in-chief says there “is serious reason to doubt the allegations,” on the ground that they want to leave it to the public to decide whether to believe it.
But even if one believes there is no such case where that is justified, yesterday’s circumstances presented the most compelling scenario possible for doing this. Once CNN strongly hinted at these allegations, it left it to the public imagination to conjure up the dirt Russiapost was originally published on this site